Wednesday, May 21, 2014

Chapter Seven — 2012 Stats — Annual Conference Worship Attendance, Membership, and Participation Ratio

Recently the United Methodist Reporter has posted comments from a 2011 blog based on the 2009 statistics.

I thought it would be interesting to see what the 2012 statistics showed for the same information. Below you will find a chart that lists each annual conference with the following items:

Average worship attendance: This is the sum of average weekly attendance for all reporting churches in 2012

Worship rank: This is how the annual conference ranks in comparison to other annual conferences related to worship attendance. (Florida had the highest average worship attendance and Alaska had the lowest)

Membership: This is the sum of total membership for all reporting churches in 2012

Membership Rank: This is how the annual conference ranks in comparison to other annual conferences related to membership. (North Georgia has the largest membership and Alaska has the smallest)

Participation Ratio: This is the ratio of total average worship attendance divided by total membership, expressed as a percentage. (For the whole church in the U.S. the participation ratio is 39.5%)

Participation Rank: This is how the annual conference ranks in comparison to other annual conferences related to participation ratio. (Desert Southwest has the highest participation ratio and Oklahoma has the lowest.)

As with all statistics, the numbers themselves don't provide conclusive information about the annual conference vitality. They do lead to interesting questions that may shed light on issues related to annual conference vitality. Here are a few questions that the numbers raised for me.

• If the annual conference is in an area where the United Methodist Church has traditionally been the most prominent church, is there a greater pressure to not remove people by charge conference action, thus reducing the participation ratio?

• We know from other studies that younger people  attend worship on a less frequent basis than do older people. So is an increasing membership and a declining participation ratio an indicator of reaching a younger demographic?

• There is some evidence that younger people are less likely to become members. So is a declining membership and an increasing participation ratio an indicator of reaching a younger demographic?

• How significant are weather patterns in relationship to participation ratios?


Annual ConferenceWorship attendanceWorship rankMembershipMember RankParticipation RatioParticipation Rank
Alabama- West Florida67781151450492445.35%19
Alaska20545435085458.55%4
Arkansas51986261348642638.55%35
Baltimore-Washington64415171737911437.06%40
Cal-Nevada3246141758264242.81%22
Cal-Pac4804730762374163.02%2
Central Texas47040331668591728.19%52
Dakotas2042748365124955.95%7
Desert Southwest2488547358835069.35%1
Detroit66512161255433052.98%8
East Ohio61024201581692038.58%33
Eastern Pennsylvania41819351109983337.68%38
Florida1335771263274550.74%10
Great Plains909978223009940.80%27
Greater New Jersey4731131924033751.20%9
Holston68467131654551841.38%23
Illinois Great Rivers63718191337532747.64%17
Indiana11135241965641056.65%6
Iowa54857251716941531.95%48
Kentucky/RedBird56963221536302237.08%39
Louisiana41185361209353134.06%46
Memphis2995346821174036.48%42
Minnesota3225542677314447.62%18
Mississippi69618121793201238.82%32
Missouri80946101634491949.52%12
New England3151644913333834.51%45
New Mexico1412651344405141.02%26
New York33797401102293430.66%51
North Alabama68132141354582550.30%11
North Carolina7974311229064834.81%44
North Georgia1271862363505134.99%43
North Texas59943211488912340.26%29
Northern Illinois3596738941963638.18%37
Northwest Texas1910750621004630.77%50
Oklahoma/OIM5651223240757623.47%54
Oregon-Idaho1366052279175248.93%14
Pacific Northwest1995449460854843.30%21
Peninsula-Delaware3175343828013938.35%36
Rio Texas50009281279712939.08%31
Rocky Mountain3025745633184547.79%16
South Carolina907909235520738.55%34
South Georgia50916271281202839.99%30
Susquehanna63988181549942141.28%24
Tennessee48435291189163240.73%28
Texas1052316284206437.03%41
Upper New York47074321682411627.98%53
Virginia1050187332637231.57%49
West Michigan3597537605704759.39%3
West Ohio10998351880591158.48%5
West Virginia4361334987103544.18%20
Western North Carolina1175663286537341.03%25
Western Pennsylvania56205241739281332.32%47
Wisconsin3588839737784348.64%15
Yellowstone619353126115349.11%13



The statistical data included herein were provided at no charge by the General Council on Finance and Administration of The United Methodist Church (GCFA) and may be obtained directly from GCFA, PO Box 340020, Nashville, TN 37203-0029. This data is proprietary and is owned by GCFA and may not be used in any commercial or exploitative way, to make a financial profit, or in a manner that defames the United Methodist denomination or its agencies or organizations. GCFA does not endorse any particular use of the data or accept responsibility for its interpretation or analysis by another.

Monday, May 19, 2014

Chapter Six — 2012 Stats — Attending a Congregation that is Predominantly the Same Ethnicity as Your Own

The last chapter of Stories From the Spreadsheet looked at ethnicity as a percentage of membership. This chapter looks at the percentages of United Methodists that attend a congregation which is predominantly of the same ethnicity as they are . Note that for these results “predominantly” is defined as 50% or more.  Please remember that this is all based upon what congregations reported. Since most congregations don’t ask about a person’s ethnic identity, in many cases the reported figures may be an estimate made by the person filling in the statistics sheet.  So while reality is probably somewhat different, these figures should give us a pretty good ball-park figure. 

A few things that I thought were interesting:
• Compared to 2010 statistics there has been a tiny decline in the percentage of African Americans, Hispanic Americans, Native Americans, and Pacific Islanders that attend a congregation which is predominantly of the same ethnicity as they are. There has been a tiny increase for Asian Americans, and Euro-American percentages have stayed the same. However, all of these changes are probably not large enough to be statistically significant. You can see the 2010 breakdown at http://spreadsheetstories.blogspot.com/2012/06/chapter-four.html

 • African American United Methodists in the Western Jurisdiction are much less likely to attend a predominantly African American congregation than are African American United Methodists in any other jurisdiction. 

• In every jurisdiction Hispanic Americans are more likely to attend a predominantly non-Hispanic congregation than a predominantly Hispanic congregation.

• Only in the Western Jurisdiction are Pacific Islander United Methodists more likely to attend a predominantly Pacific Islander congregation than a predominantly non-Pacific Islander congregation.

• Only in the Southeastern Jurisdiction are Native American United Methodists more likely to attend a predominantly Native American congregation than a predominantly non-Native American congregation.

• No matter where they live, it is highly unlikely that a Euro American United Methodist will belong to a congregation that is predominantly non-Euro American.


Among all U.S. Congregations
85.1% of African American United Methodists attended predominantly African American congregations
66.2% of Asian American United Methodists attended predominantly Asian American congregations
34% of Hispanic American United Methodists attended predominantly Hispanic American congregations
44.8% of Native American United Methodists attended predominantly Native American congregations
37.5% of Pacific Islander United Methodists attended predominantly Pacific Islander congregations
99.7% of Euro American United Methodists attend predominantly Euro American congregations

In the Northeastern Jurisdiction
84.3% of African American United Methodists attended predominantly African American congregations
74.3% of Asian American United Methodists attended predominantly Asian American congregations
44.4% of Hispanic American United Methodists attended predominantly Hispanic American congregations
27.9% of Native American United Methodists attended predominantly Native American congregations
0% of Pacific Islander United Methodists attended predominantly Pacific Islander congregations
99.5% of Euro American United Methodists attend predominantly Euro American congregations

In the Southeastern Jurisdiction
89.3% of African American United Methodists attended predominantly African American congregations
51.2% of Asian American United Methodists attended predominantly Asian American congregations
18.1% of Hispanic American United Methodists attended predominantly Hispanic American congregations
65.7% of Native American United Methodists attended predominantly Native American congregations
0% of Pacific Islander United Methodists attended predominantly Pacific Islander congregations
99.9% of Euro American United Methodists attend predominantly Euro American congregations

In the South Central Jurisdiction
86.2% of African American United Methodists attended predominantly African American congregations
49.1% of Asian American United Methodists attended predominantly Asian American congregations
42.1% of Hispanic American United Methodists attended predominantly Hispanic American congregations
43.7% of Native American United Methodists attended predominantly Native American congregations
16.3% of Pacific Islander United Methodists attended predominantly Pacific Islander congregations
99.8% of Euro American United Methodists attend predominantly Euro American congregations

In the Western Jurisdiction
53.7% of African American United Methodists attended predominantly African American congregations
74.4% of Asian American United Methodists attended predominantly Asian American congregations
18.8% of Hispanic American United Methodists attended predominantly Hispanic American congregations
20% of Native American United Methodists attended predominantly Native American congregations
55.7% of Pacific Islander United Methodists attended predominantly Pacific Islander congregations
97.7% of Euro American United Methodists attend predominantly Euro American congregations

In the North Central Jurisdiction
73.4% of African American United Methodists attended predominantly African American congregations
61.2% of Asian American United Methodists attended predominantly Asian American congregations
33.4% of Hispanic American United Methodists attended predominantly Hispanic American congregations
30.7% of Native American United Methodists attended predominantly Native American congregations
0% of Pacific Islander United Methodists attended predominantly Pacific Islander congregations
99.9% of Euro American United Methodists attend predominantly Euro American congregations

The statistical data included herein were provided at no charge by the General Council on Finance and Administration of The United Methodist Church (GCFA) and may be obtained directly from GCFA, PO Box 340020, Nashville, TN 37203-0029. This data is proprietary and is owned by GCFA and may not be used in any commercial or exploitative way, to make a financial profit, or in a manner that defames the United Methodist denomination or its agencies or organizations. GCFA does not endorse any particular use of the data or accept responsibility for its interpretation or analysis by another.

Wednesday, May 7, 2014

Chapter Five - 2012 Stats - Ethnicity in Jurisdictions

This chapter looks a little more closely at ethnicity as a percentage of membership and U.S. population. As with previous issues, these figures are based on congregations with at least five members.

 A few things that I noticed were:
  • As a percentage of the jurisdiction, the highest percentage of African Americans is in the Northeastern Jurisdiction
  • As a percentage of the jurisdiction, the highest percentages of Asian Americans, Hispanic Americans, Pacific Islanders, and Multi-racial members are in the Western Jurisdiction.
  • As a percentage of the jurisdiction, the highest percentage of Native Americans is in the South Central Jurisdiction.
  • As a percentage of the jurisdiction, the highest percentage of Euro Americans is in the North Central Jurisdiction.

U.S. Population based on data from the U.S. Census Bureau
13.1% -  African American
5.1% -  Asian American
16.9%  - Hispanic American
1.2% - Native American
63% - Euro American
.2% - Pacific Islander
2.4% - Multi-racial

All Jurisdictions Combined (32440 Congregations)
5.99% -  African American
1.25% -  Asian American
1.01%  - Hispanic American
.29% - Native American
89.94% - Euro American
.18% - Pacific Islander
.68% - Multi-racial
.66% - No ethnicity reported

Western Jurisdiction (1719 Congregations)
4.64% -  African American
9.73% -  Asian American
2.24%  - Hispanic American
.35% - Native American
77.4% - Euro American
2.52% - Pacific Islander
1.91% - Multi-racial
1.21% - No ethnicity reported

South Central Jurisdiction (5633 Congregations)
5.7% - African American
.55% - Asian American
2.12% - Hispanic American
.8% - Native American
89.95% - Euro American
.08% - Pacific Islander
.76% - Multi-racial
.04% - No ethnicity reported

North Central Jurisdiction (6848 Congregations)
2.54% - African American
.85% - Asian American
.44% - Hispanic American
.11% - Native American
93.87% - Euro American
.06% - Pacific Islander
.82% - Multi-racial
1.31% - No ethnicity reported

Southeastern Jurisdiction (11339 Congregations)
7.21% - African American
.56% - Asian American
.59% - Hispanic American
.15% - Native American
90.52% - Euro American
.05% - Pacific Islander
.35% - Multi-racial
.57% - No ethnicity reported

Northeastern Jurisdiction (6901 Congregations)
7.52% - African American
1.88% - Asian American
.7% - Hispanic American
.11% - Native American
88.04% - Euro American
.09% - Pacific Islander
.82% - Multi-racial
.27% - No ethnicity reported

If you would like to take a look at how this compares to the 2010 figures, you can find that information at: http://spreadsheetstories.blogspot.com/2012/06/chapter-two.html

The statistical data included herein were provided at no charge by the General Council on Finance and Administration of The United Methodist Church (GCFA) and may be obtained directly from GCFA, PO Box 340020, Nashville, TN 37203-0029. This data is proprietary and is owned by GCFA and may not be used in any commercial or exploitative way, to make a financial profit, or in a manner that defames the United Methodist denomination or its agencies or organizations. GCFA does not endorse any particular use of the data or accept responsibility for its interpretation or analysis by another.

Thursday, May 1, 2014

Chapter Four - 2012 Stats - Average Worship Attendance in Relationship to Membership, Professions of Faith, and Apportionment Giving

The last chapter of Stories from the Spreadsheet looked at groupings based on membership. This issue looks at groupings  based on average worship attendance. These numbers are based on churches that report at least five members and an average worship attendance of at least one.

A few interesting things to note are:
As a group churches with an average worship attendance of
    -  1 to 50 decreased in worship attendance by 3.06%, 
    -  51 to 200 decreased in worship attendance by .92% 
    -  201 to 900 increased in worship attendance by .52%
    -  901 or greater decreased in worship attendance by .44%

- 76% of  congregations have an average worship attendance of 100 or less
- 34% of United Methodists are members of a congregation with an average attendance of 100 or less

- 18% of congregations have an average worship attendance of 101  to 300 
- 33% of United Methodists are members of a congregation with an ave. attendance of 101 to 300

- 5% of congregations have an average worship attendance of over 300
- 34% of United Methodists are members of a congregation with and average attendance of over 300

- Churches with an average worship attendance of between 701 and 800 showed the largest percentage increase in worship attendance, the highest participation ratio, and the second highest apportionment payment percentage.

Here is the more detailed breakdown:
Churches with an average worship attendance of 1 to 50
  • 53% of congregations
  • 15% of United Methodists
  • 15% of worshippers
  • 2.32% decrease in membership
  • 3.06 % decrease in worship attendance
  • 81.98% apportionment payment
  • 11% of professions of faith
  • 40.72% participation ratio

Churches with an average worship attendance of 51 to 100
  • 23% of congregations
  • 18% of United Methodists
  • 18% of worshippers
  • 1.2% decrease in members
  • .88% decrease in worship attendance
  • 81.43% apportionment payment
  • 18% of professions of faith
  • 39.88% participation ratio

Churches with an average worship attendance of 101 to 200
  • 13% of congregations
  • 21% of United Methodists
  • 21% of worshippers
  • 1.29% decrease in members
  • .96% decrease in worship attendance
  • 85.24% apportionment payment
  • 21% of professions of faith
  •  39.84% participation ratio

Churches with an average worship attendance of 201 to 300
  • 4% of congregations
  • 12% of United Methodists
  • 12% of worshippers
  • .82% decrease in members
  • .13% increase in worship attendance
  • 88.75% apportionment payment
  • 12% of professions of faith
  • 40.5% participation ratio

Churches with an average worship attendance of 301 to 400
  • 2% of congregations
  • 8% of United Methodist
  • 8% of worshippers
  • 1.22% decrease in membership
  • .93% increase in worship attendance
  • 93.78% apportionment payment
  • 8% or professions of faith
  • 39.89% participation ratio

Churches with an average worship attendance of 401 to 500
  • 1% of congregations
  • 5% of United Methodists
  • 5% of worshippers
  • .52% decrease in membership
  • .25% increase in worship attendance
  • 92.98% apportionment payment
  • 6% of professions of faith
  • 40.7% participation ratio

Churches with an average worship attendance of 501 to 600
  • .64% of congregations
  • 4% of United Methodists
  • 4% of worshippers
  • .01% increase in membership
  • 1.0% increase in worship attendance
  • 95.27% apportionment payment
  • 4% of professions of faith
  • 42.31% participation ratio

Churches with an average worship attendance of 601 to 700
  • .43% of congregations
  • 3% of United Methodists
  • 3% of worshippers
  • .21% increase in membership
  • .02% decrease in worship attendance
  • 94.5% apportionment payment
  • 3% of professions of faith
  • 39.51% participation ratio

Churches with an average worship attendance of  701 to 800
  • .23% of congregations
  • 1.6% of United Methodists
  • 1.9% of worshippers
  • .08% increase in membership
  • 1.71% increase in worship attendance
  • 96.46% apportionment payment
  • 1.9% of professions of faith
  • 47.48% participation ratio

Churches with an average worship attendance of 801 –900
  • .15% of congregations
  • 1.4% of United Methodists
  • 1.4% of worshippers
  • .36% increase in membership
  • 1.03% increase in worship attendance
  • 87.95% apportionment payment
  • 1.7% of professions of faith
  • 38.57% participation ratio

Churches with an average worship attendance of 901-1000
  • .11% of congregations
  • 1.3% of United Methodists
  • 1.2 % of worshippers
  • .54% increase in membership
  • .9% decrease in worship attendance
  • 93.11% apportionment payment
  • 1.3% of professions of faith
  • 36.89% participation ratio

Churches with an average worship attendance of 1001 to 1500
  • .33% of congregations
  • 5% of United Methodists
  • 4% of worshippers
  • 1.02% increase in membership
  • .35% decrease in worship attendance
  • 96.82% apportionment payment
  • 6% of professions of faith
  • 37.21% participation ratio
  
Churches with an average worship attendance of greater than 1500
  • .22% of congregations
  • 5% of United Methodists
  • 6% of worshippers
  • 1.92% increase in membership
  • .4% decrease in worship attendance
  • 89.4% apportionment payment
  • 6% of professions of faith
  • 46.34% participation ratio

(Due to rounding numbers do not add up to exactly 100%)
 
The statistical data included herein were provided at no charge by the General Council on Finance and Administration of The United Methodist Church (GCFA) and may be obtained directly from GCFA, PO Box 340020, Nashville, TN 37203-0029. This data is proprietary and is owned by GCFA and may not be used in any commercial or exploitative way, to make a financial profit, or in a manner that defames the United Methodist denomination or its agencies or organizations. GCFA does not endorse any particular use of the data or accept responsibility for its interpretation or analysis by another.